Sanibel, FL Real Estate Search

Sanibel, FL Homes for Sale

Overview of Sanibel Real Estate Market

Sanibel, Florida, is renowned for its breathtaking beaches, unique wildlife, and laid-back lifestyle, making it a desirable location for homebuyers and investors alike. The real estate market on Sanibel Island has experienced fluctuating trends, but it continues to attract a diverse range of buyers. Many seek vacation homes or investment properties, while others look for primary residences in this idyllic setting. The appeal of the island, with its abundant recreational opportunities and natural beauty, contributes to the persistent demand for real estate.

Types of Properties Available

The real estate landscape in Sanibel offers a variety of property types, catering to different preferences and budgets. Buyers can find charming beach cottages, luxurious waterfront estates, and modern condominiums, each with unique amenities. Many properties feature direct access to sandy beaches or stunning waterfront views, which enhance their value and desirability. Additionally, there are options for new constructions as well as historic homes, giving buyers plenty of choices to fit their lifestyle and investment goals.

Environmental Considerations

Given Sanibel's location along the Gulf of Mexico, environmental considerations play a significant role in real estate decisions. The island is dedicated to preserving its natural landscapes, wildlife habitats, and eco-friendly practices. This commitment aligns tightly with the interests of potential homeowners who are environmentally conscious. Buyers are often drawn to properties that offer sustainable living options and easy access to nature trails, parks, and wildlife refuges, which are abundant on the island. Local regulations often encourage environmentally friendly building practices, further enhancing the appeal of homes in the area.

Investment Potential and Market Trends

Investing in Sanibel real estate presents opportunities due to the island's reputation as a vacation destination. Many property owners take advantage of short-term rental possibilities to generate income while enjoying their residences. The market has shown resilience even in challenging economic conditions, with values remaining relatively stable compared to other areas. However, potential investors should remain informed about market trends, property values, and local regulations affecting rentals to make informed investment decisions.

The Sanibel Lifestyle

Sanibel Island’s distinct lifestyle is another factor driving real estate interest. The island’s laid-back atmosphere, coupled with its abundant outdoor activities—such as biking, kayaking, and shelling—enhances its attractiveness. Residents benefit from a strong sense of community and access to top-rated schools, making it appealing for families seeking a balanced life. Additionally, the island boasts boutique shops, fine dining, and cultural activities, providing a fulfilling life for residents. The overall lifestyle complements the real estate market, creating an enduring demand for homes in this picturesque Floridian enclave.

Our website features the best Sanibel, FL real estate search for homes available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Sanibel, FL Homes for Sale

Avg. No of Beds
Avg. No of Baths
Avg. Living Ft2
Avg. Listing Price
Cost per ft2
Days on Market

Curious about what’s happening in the Sanibel, FL real estate market? Sign up for a  Sanibel, FL Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Sanibel, FL Homes for Sale

$2,899,000
3 Beds 4 Baths Belle Meade SubDv.
Stunning Elevated Custom Home on Sanibel River - Your Dream Oasis Awaits! Welcome to your own slice of paradise in Sanibel, Florida! This spectacular 2023 custom-built elevated home combines luxury, resilience, and natural beauty, providing the perfect sanctuary for relaxation and adventure. Key Features: Hurricane-Resistant Design:Built to withstand the elements, this home is equipped with advanced hurricane-resistant windows and doors, ensuring peace of mind during storm season. Prime Location on Sanibel River: Nestled along the tranquil banks of the Sanibel River, you'll enjoy breathtaking views and direct access to serene waterways ideal for kayaking, fishing, and exploring. Expansive Open-Concept Living: Step inside to a bright and airy open-concept layout, where spacious living areas seamlessly flow into one another. High ceilings and large windows flood the interior with natural light, creating a welcoming atmosphere. Gourmet Kitchen: The heart of the home features a state-of-the-art kitchen complete with high-end Dacor appliances, quartz countertops, and ample cabinet space—perfect for culinary enthusiasts and family gatherings. Luxurious Primary Suite: The generous master suite offers a tranquil retreat, complete with a spa-like ensuite bath and private access to a covered balcony overlooking the river—an ideal spot for sipping morning coffee or enjoying evening sunsets. Entertainment-Ready Outdoor Space: Step outside to your elevated outdoor oasis, featuring a sparkling heated pool, expansive deck, and lush landscaping—all designed for ultimate relaxation and entertaining friends and family. Advanced Power Solutions: This home comes equipped with a robust 45KW generator, ensuring you’ll never be without power, no matter the weather. Proximity to Sanibel's Best: Enjoy easy access to Sanibel’s renowned beaches, shopping, dining, and recreational activities. Embrace the island lifestyle with abundant wildlife, pristine nature trails, and vibrant community events just moments away. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a meticulously crafted elevated home on the beautiful Sanibel River, designed for both luxury and durability. Schedule your private showing today and start living the Sanibel dream!

9345 Dimmick Drive, Sanibel

$2,450,000
4 Beds 4 Baths Gulf Ridge Sub SubDv.
Built in 2017 with resiliency in mind, elevated, concrete construction with metal roof and all impact doors and windows set the stage for the welcoming oasis found inside. When you step into the ground floor entrance you know you are home with a beautiful open stairway or elevator access leading to a spacious living room that provides sweeping views of natural water and wildlife habitat. A beautifully finished kitchen will make any home chef comfortable with large cooktop, built in microwave, oven and warming drawer, the prep island with sink adds to the incredible efficiency. Beautiful wood cabinetry and granite countertops deliver the fine coastal elegance found in the kitchen and throughout the home. The primary suite is situated with privacy and comfort in mind with lovely views from the many windows, a custom closet/dressing room and well defined bathroom with separate sinks, walk-in shower and soaking tub. Two guest bedrooms include on-suite baths, the third guest bedroom, has been used as an office, has a full bath located adjacent to it. All of this is accompanied by lovely landscaping and natural outdoor area, with screened lanai and spacious pool and pool area. The ample sized 3 car garage offers plenty of additional parking and storage space and custom flood panels provide additional protection to the entry foyer. The Gulf Ridge community includes 3 beach accesses making the beach just steps away from anywhere in the community.

4988 Joewood Drive, Sanibel

$1,050,000
4 Beds 3 Baths Lake Murex SubDv.
This spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home sits on an oversized lot and is your chance to create the perfect island retreat. Renovations are 71% complete, according to the City of Sanibel. House was gutted and reconfigured with a modern open floor plan, soaring ceilings, and large grey tile flooring throughout. The kitchen features custom cabinets from a designer showroom in Naples and are in place, but not completely installed, large, remodeled bathrooms give a spa like feeling, and needs to be completed (fixtures, shower doors, counter tops installed in guest bathroom, and vanity with countertop installed in guest suite). This home was purchased by some investors after Hurricane Ian and have found themselves short on funds to complete the project. Roof was damaged from the storm. Current owners started the process, removed the old roof, and got it dried in, but new owners will need to finish the project. Trim work inside needs to be finishes, along with hanging closet doors, etc. Front porch staircase needs to be redone, deck railings and stairs off the back deck need to be added for safety. House also needs some soffit, siding, and gutter repairs. Pool deck needs some finishing touches, along with all new equipment. There are various other projects that need to be completed; however, a lot of the materials are on-site. Enjoy sunset views over Lake Murex from the deck, take a short walk to the beach, or relax in the pool. The elevated home offers plenty of garage space for cars, toys, and more. Sold AS/IS with the right to inspect— Power is not on. Seize this opportunity to add the finishing touches and turn this home into a showstopper!

497 Lake Murex Circle, Sanibel

$1,899,000
3 Beds 4 Baths Tigua Cay Condo SubDv.
UNIQUE TURNKEY GULF FRONTAGE TOWNHOUSE WITH PRIVATE ELEVATOR!! Welcome to your dream coastal retreat! This stunning 2-story townhouse offers 2,288 sq ft of luxurious living space in a unique year-round private residential family setting—perfect for those seeking tranquility and exclusivity, as rentals are not permitted. Nestled right on the beach, this property boasts 250 feet of pristine Gulf frontage, allowing you to soak in breathtaking views and the soothing sound of waves just steps from your door. Inside, you'll find brand-new impact windows that not only enhance your home's beauty but also ensure your peace of mind. The interior is free from hurricane damage and water intrusion, providing a worry-free environment for your family. As you enter through your private elevator, you’ll be greeted by a magnificent great room featuring elegant stone flooring, striking 2-story coral walls, and a cozy fireplace that adds warmth and character. Floor-to-ceiling windows flood the space with natural light, while electric shutters offer convenience and privacy. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's delight, equipped with custom wood cabinetry and high-end appliances, making it the perfect space for culinary creativity. The primary bedroom suite offers deck access, allowing you to enjoy stunning sunrises or sunsets from the comfort of your own space. Additional highlights include a spacious 2-car garage with a brand-new garage door, ample extra storage, and a laundry room conveniently located within the unit. Your new home will also feature a surround sound system and ADT security throughout for added comfort and safety. Outside, a new pool is set to be completed this fall, creating an inviting oasis for relaxation and entertainment. Plus, an expansive wood dock will enhance your outdoor experience, perfect for enjoying the coastal lifestyle. Don’t miss the opportunity to make this exceptional townhouse your own—a true sanctuary by the sea! Contact us today for a private showing and start living the beach life you’ve always dreamed of!

487 E Gulf Drive, Sanibel

$1,200,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Sundial Of Sanibel SubDv.
Welcome to your dream beachfront condo on Sanibel Island! Just a short distance from Fort Myers, this tropical island paradise is perfect for your second home. Spend your mornings collecting seashells on the world-famous white-sand beaches, then immerse yourself in the island’s stunning natural beauty in the afternoon. With over half of the island protected as nature reserves, there’s plenty to explore. Known as the Seashell Capital of the World, Sanibel boasts 25+ miles of bike paths, 50 types of fish, and over 250 varieties of seashells! Casual is the order of the day on Sanibel Island with lots of shabby chic shops and galleries all along Periwinkle Way. At days end enjoy spectacular sunsets and indulge in fresh Gulf cuisine or savor homemade Italian dishes at local restaurants. With no traffic lights and buildings limited to the height of the tallest palm tree, the enchanting views are yours to enjoy, day and night. This charming third-floor 2-bedroom beachfront condo comes fully furnished and features an additional den that can easily serve as a third bedroom. The inviting living area opens up to a spacious balcony, where you can soak in breathtaking views of the Gulf while sipping your morning coffee or unwinding with a sunset cocktail and enjoying the serene coastal scenery. It’s the perfect blend of comfort and stunning natural beauty! Not only is this a fantastic place to call home, this property also offers the option to enroll in the Sundial Beach Resort & Spa rental program. With on-site management, it’s a lucrative investment opportunity for those looking to make the most of their beachfront getaway. Enjoy the numerous amenities, including multiple swimming pools, tennis and pickleball courts, a fitness center, and delightful on-site restaurants. Here you will find the perfect blend of relaxation and investment potential in this stunning tropical setting! Come experience the magic of island living! With its breathtaking views, pristine beaches, and vibrant community, this is a place where every day feels like a vacation.

1401 Middle Gulf Drive Unit 302L, Sanibel

$960,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Lighthouse Point Condo SubDv.
Beautifully furnished in Aug 2024 (furnishings are negotiable) and reintroduced to the market in Sept 2024. Experience the best of island living with this exquisite 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom condo, masterfully constructed 2024 interior by Claremont, and featuring a 3-year transferrable warranty for your peace of mind. Nestled just steps away from the renowned Sanibel Lighthouse Beach, the gulf and the bay, this condo offers a perfect blend of luxury and location with unparalleled shelling opportunities and amazing sunsets. Step inside to discover a beautifully appointed interior with PGT Impact Glass windows that allow lots of natural light while providing superior protection. The kitchen is a chef's dream, boasting stunning quartz countertops, upgraded handcrafted Pearl Mosaic glass backsplash, soft-close cabinets and drawers, lots of kitchen countertop space and storage and all-new 2024 appliances including a 20 bottle wine cooler. The master bath features a full custom walk in shower with bench, glass wall, and custom tile throughout it and the spare bathroom. The spacious sunroom is perfect for relaxing with a good book or entertaining guests, while the extra storage throughout the condo ensures that everything has its place. Enjoy the convenience of a carport and outside storage for your beach supplies and rest easy knowing your new home comes with a new AC unit and hot water tank. Upgraded crown molding and baseboards add a touch of elegance throughout. This condo is designed to impress and built to last, offering a serene retreat in one of Sanibel's most sought-after locations. Did I mention it is pet friendly as well? Don’t miss the opportunity to make this luxurious property your own and enjoy island living at its finest. Schedule a viewing today and step into your dream home!

200 Periwinkle Way Unit 114, Sanibel

$450,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Blind Pass Condo SubDv.
This first-floor condo in Blind Pass offers a unique "white box" opportunity, providing a blank canvas for you to create your ideal island retreat. Nestled on Sanibel Island's west end, the condo is just a short stroll from Bowman’s Beach, renowned for its exceptional shelling and close to the JN Ding Darling Wildlife Refuge. Surrounded by tropical vegetation, the path to the beach includes a scenic walk over a wooden footbridge spanning the bayou. Enjoy a morning coffee on the screened lanai on the tranquil side of the property and later in the day, meander down to the beach with your favorite refreshments to savor the stunning sunsets over the water. Blind Pass is a quaint complex of 7 buildings with 101 units, boasting resort-like amenities such as a heated pool, tennis courts, gas grills, and a community room. The unit features easy ground-level access and parking just beyond the lanai, a newly added A/C, and hurricane-proof windows and slider. The spacious 1200 sq ft offers a generous open living area with a split bedroom design, ideal for privacy and comfort. including an en-suite master bedroom. Ideal for both personal enjoyment and as an investment, the property comes with an optional onsite rental team to manage vacation rentals. Located just minutes from downtown Sanibel and Captiva Island, and directly connected to Sanibel’s extensive bike paths, this condo offers the perfect blend of secluded beach living and convenient access to local amenities. This opportunity is ideal for anyone dreaming of creating their own beachside retreat, blending the allure of a custom-designed home with the amenities and ease of resort-style living.

5117 Sea Bell Road Unit C101, Sanibel

$1,750,000
3 Beds 3 Baths Dunes At Sanibel Island SubDv.
CALLING ALL GOLFERS!!! The MOST perfect spot on The Dunes with panoramic views and an incredible custom home! Welcome to 1143 Sand Castle Road, a stunningly remodeled oasis nestled in the heart of Sanibel, Florida. This exquisite home boasts a seamless blend of modern elegance and coastal charm, offering an unparalleled living experience. Every detail of this property has been thoughtfully updated (with permits), from the open-concept living spaces to the high-end finishes throughout, all with permits and to the highest quality! As you step inside, you are greeted by an abundance of natural light that highlights the spaciousness of the interior. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring top-of-the-line appliances, custom cabinetry, and a large kitchen island perfect for entertaining. Stunning statement quartz, two refrigerators, this is a chef's dream - all with panoramic views of the golf course! The living and dining areas flow effortlessly, creating a perfect setting for both relaxation and social gatherings. The master suite is a true retreat, complete with a luxurious en-suite bathroom and private access to the expansive outdoor living space. A den or additional room is attached to the master and makes a perfect space for an office, expanded master or workout room. Additional bedrooms are generously sized, each with its own unique charm and style. Step outside to discover paradise. One of the BEST golf course views of both water and the greens, the view will take your breathe away! Located on a corner "tip" lot with views from every angle - nothing better! The sparkling pool invites you to take a refreshing dip, while the surrounding patio offers ample space for lounging and soaking in the Florida sun. An additional enclosed patio and dining area are perfect for alfresco meals, and the lush landscaping provides a serene backdrop. One of the most breathtaking features of this home is its location, overlooking the meticulously manicured greens of the nearby golf course. Whether you're an avid golfer or simply appreciate the beauty of a well-kept course, the views from your backyard are sure to impress. The Dunes is a semi private golf course with an 18 hole championship course, tennis, pickleball and so much more! Known as a challenging yet suitable course for all skill sets, you are surrounded by a world class course as well as the beauty of the Islands. This home at 1143 Sand Castle Road is more than just a place to live; it's a lifestyle. With its prime location, modern upgrades, and luxurious amenities, this property offers a unique opportunity to experience the best of Sanibel Island living. Close to beaches, shopping and the Sanibel bridge, this beautiful home checks all the boxes!

1143 Sand Castle Road, Sanibel

$895,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Gumbo Limbo SubDv.
Discover and enjoy the beautiful life of Sanibel Island. Surrounded by natural beauty, wildlife, beaches, boating, water sports, shopping, dining, entertainment, nature trails, framer market, and tons of outdoor activities. Located in the sought-after neighborhood of Gumbo Limbo just minutes from the Sanibel Causeway. You will love this recently renovated immaculate Lake Front Coastal Modern Rustic Style Pool Home. Welcome to1643 Bunting Lane, Sanibel Fl 33957. This beautiful highly energy-efficient home offers astonishing finishes from wood plank ceilings, custom-designed bathrooms & kitchens, high-end flooring, sliding barn doors, LED lighting throughout the home, new light fixers and fans, high-end kitchen appliances, and bathroom finishes. Remote window blinds covers and whole house dehumidifier. Metal roof with extended life paint protection, impact-rated exterior, and garage doors. New insulation in the attic, new AC and ductwork, tankless water heater, upgraded electrical panel, epoxy flooring, storage room with an indoor & outdoor access door, great size storage room perfect for storing kayaks, bikes, and beach gear, plus garage cabinets (a ton of storage space), and utility sink. Upgraded water lines, all electrical outlets upgraded, new pool heater, resurfaced pool, free span pool cage, new sprinkler system, fenced park-like sitting sanctuary with views of the conservation land and lake. Fresh exterior paint and new sod and crushed shells all around the home adding to the wonderful landscape. Surrounded by wonderful palm trees, mature native vegetation lush landscaping, and stunning lake views, you will enjoy the tropical living and wildlife. This beautiful move-in ready home is the Perfect Home for a permanent residence or an investment retreat vacation home. Dreams do come True! Your Island Home is Right Here! Look No Feather Book Your Showing Today! Sanibel the Paradise Island!

1643 Bunting Lane, Sanibel

$875,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Sanibel Bayous SubDv.
Welcome to this beautifully updated residence on Sanibel Island just minutes from the beach, where modern luxury meets island serenity. This exceptional home has been thoughtfully renovated to provide the ultimate in comfort and style. Featuring all-new hurricane glass windows and sliding doors, a new roof, soffit, and seamless gutters provide long-lasting protection and easy maintenance. With a range of new systems including a jacuzzi tub, 200 Amp electric panel, air conditioning compressor and handler, water softener system, and a new washer and 220 dryer. Step inside to find stunning wood-look tile floors that extend throughout the open living spaces. The centerpiece is a grand 48 sq ft marble stone fireplace, providing a touch of sophistication. The custom galley-style kitchen is a chef’s dream, boasting quartz countertops, a white farmhouse sink, and all-new stainless steel appliances. Recessed lighting enhances the modern aesthetic. The screened lanai with vanilla coconut pavers offers a perfect setting for outdoor relaxation, while the double-wide driveway with paver accents and trim adds to the home's curb appeal. Mature palm trees and fruit trees surround the property, creating a tropical paradise on a private half-acre+ lot that includes a new irrigation system with Wi-Fi control that keeps the landscaping vibrant and lush with minimal effort. Embrace the island lifestyle! Don't miss the chance to make this exceptional property your new haven.

4636 Buck Key Road, Sanibel

$999,000
3 Beds 2 Baths Mariner Pointe Condo SubDv.
Discover a rare gem at Mariner Pointe Unit 941, one of only 4 unobstructed direct bayfront 3-bedroom Ground Floor condos, and the most desirable of them all. This exceptional unit is perfectly positioned with the main pool, tennis and pickleball courts, BBQ grills, and your assigned parking spot just outside your front door. Out the back door, you're greeted by the serene beauty of the bay, where sailboats, birds, and dolphins create a picturesque scene along with the bayfront boardwalk which leads to the private fishing pier. The thoughtfully designed floor plan maximizes every stunning view, with two bayfront lanais—one off the spacious living area and the other off the master bedroom. The open-plan kitchen flows seamlessly into the living space, leading directly onto the lanai, perfect for enjoying the coastal breeze and breathtaking vistas. The master bedroom offers a peaceful retreat, complete with a walk-in closet and an ensuite featuring a large shower. Washer/dryer hookups are conveniently located off the kitchen in a private closet. The guest bedrooms are generously sized, with a guest bath featuring a tub-shower combo, along with a large linen closet for additional storage. Mariner Pointe offers an array of amenities in addition there are leased boat docks, a kayak and paddleboard launch and DEEDED BEACH ACCESS. The unit will soon begin its restoration, possibly providing the new buyer a unique chance to select materials and finishes. Recently remodeled in 2022 just before Hurricane Ian, the condo will be restored to an exquisite standard, with new appliances. More information on the rebuild is expected later this month, giving you the opportunity to create the condo of your dreams in one of Sanibel's most coveted locations.

760 Sextant Drive Unit 941, Sanibel

Start Your Search